South West Farm Press Logo

Dismantling NAFTA would be ‘a blow to U.S. ag economy’

The U.S. is the world’s largest exporter of agricultural and food products, with exports now accounting for about 35 percent of the nation’s farm income, up from 28 percent in 1996. The value of ag exports has increased from $46.2 billion in 1994 to $134.9 billion in 2016.

Ron Smith 1

September 22, 2017

5 Min Read
Luis Ribera, Texas A&M AgriLife economist, checks on trade issues at his College Station office. NAFTA needs to be modernized, not scrapped, he says, and Cuba offers significant market potential for U.S. agriculture.

Agricultural exports to Mexico and Canada through the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) are too important to allow political rhetoric and the threat of U.S.-imposed tariffs to jeopardize these crucial markets, says Louis Ribera, Texas A&M AgriLife Extension economist.

Dismantling that agreement would be a significant blow to the U.S. ag economy, he says. Rather, “We need to modernize it.” Issues such as sanitary and phytosanitary certification were not as significant when the trade pact was signed, he notes. Modern technology has changed. “We also did not have the Food Safety and Modernization Act in place” at that time.

The U.S. is the world’s largest exporter of agricultural and food products, with exports now accounting for about 35 percent of the nation’s farm income, up from 28 percent in 1996. The value of ag exports has increased from $46.2 billion in 1994 to $134.9 billion in 2016.

During that same period, exports to Mexico and Canada increased from $10 billion to $38 billion — a whopping 288 percent increase — making Canada and Mexico the second and third largest markets for U.S. agricultural exports. The two countries rank first and second as agricultural trade partners for the U.S., with two-way trade values in 2016 of $41.8 billion and $40.8 billion, respectively.

Related:South Texas begins long process of digging out after Harvey

Both markets are important for Texas ag producers, Ribera says. “In 2016, Texas exports to Mexico totaled $833.5 million, of which $270.8 million was for animal products and $562.8 million was for plant products. Texas agricultural exports to Canada totaled $875.1 million, $222.6 million in animal products and $652.6 million in plant products.


How does NAFTA fit into the relationship? The agreement was simultaneously implemented in the three countries Jan. 1, 1994, eliminating most tariffs on trade between the nations.

Trade and NAFTA support a lot of jobs, Ribera says. “Many synergies exist between countries because of trade. Mexico imports more beef to the U.S. than it buys. But Mexico buys a lot of U.S corn, so a lot of our grain is used in their feedlots.

 “Fruit and vegetable trade was a big win for Mexico, while the U.S. lost some markets. Vegetable producers in the Valley were opposed to NAFTA.” The No. 1 product for Mexican export is greenhouse tomatoes. “But, proposals to protect markets usually backfire,” he says. “Trade makes efficiency happen.” The Vegetable Improvement Center at Weslaco is working to “bring produce back to Texas. We see a lot of interest, but we have to find markets. We’re currently looking for a vegetable marketing specialist.”

Mexican ag imports create opportunities in the Lower Rio Grande Valley, Ribera says. The Pharr, Texas, port of entry is expected to handle more traffic in the near future, if it doesn’t already, than the port of entry at Nogales, Ariz. That increased traffic — much of it produce from Mexico — created a demand for infrastructure to handle and distribute products to both U.S. coasts, creating jobs.

“A lot of brokers moved to Texas,” he says. “Mexican imports are creating huge economic opportunities along the International Highway — truck stops, restaurants, and other businesses.”

It’s better for America’s farmers “if we produce it, but we can’t produce year-round, so we gain advantages with the infrastructure in the Lower Rio Grande Valley.”

The possibility that Mexico will look to other suppliers for grain and other commodities is small, Ribera says. “It would be hard for Mexico to switch grain imports from the U.S. to Brazil or Argentina. Countries don’t do trade with each other — businesses trade with each other, and it’s hard to break those relationships. Trade is about business, not politics.”


No reduction in U.S. grain trade with Mexico has occurred, he says. “So far, nothing has happened, and I don’t foresee that anything will happen — unless we put a tariff on Mexican imports. “I would like to see the rhetoric surrounding NAFTA change from ‘It’s the worst deal ever’ to ‘Let’s make it better.’ We can blame NAFTA, or we can do something to compete.”

Improving efficiency, reducing costs, and branding products are possibilities. He suggests branding a product similar to the way Georgia onion growers have done with Vidalia onions.

Production costs for the Valley are not that different from Mexico, he notes, while “California’s cost of production is higher because of regulations and the price of water.”

U.S. consumers benefit from trade, Ribera says. “The U.S. has the cheapest food in the world. Consumers spend just 6.4 percent of their income for food, while Canadians spend 10 percent and Mexico’s citizens spend 20 percent. Trade allows us to have more products year-round, at a good price, and good quality. That’s the advantage.” Mexico also imports a lot of U.S. and Texas cotton.


Cuba offers U.S. agriculture — and Texas — a viable market, Ribera says. “Exports to Cuba peaked in 2008 at $658 million, 42 percent of their food imports. U.S. share was 16 percent in 2014, but in 2016, U.S. ag exports had declined to $200 million, 8 percent of the market.”

The U.S. has lost share to the European Union, Canada, Brazil, and Vietnam, among others.

Exports to Cuba have declined, he says, because of payment restrictions, including cash advance requirements. “They can’t even look at the product until they pay for it.” A $1 billion market is at stake, and “We can supply what they need.” Top demand is for poultry, meat products, milk, “things we are good at producing. Rice would be big for both Cuba and U.S. rice producers. They are one of the highest per capita consumers of rice.”

On the flip side, Cuba exports sugar — some valued-added in rum — and cigars. Location and ease of delivery would be a huge benefit to Cuba. Without the restrictions, “We could get half of that market easily,” Ribera says. Trade obstacles come from politics, he says — the long-standingembargo. “Who does it help?”


About the Author(s)

Ron Smith 1

Senior Content Director, Farm Press/Farm Progress

Ron Smith has spent more than 40 years covering Sunbelt agriculture. Ron began his career in agricultural journalism as an Experiment Station and Extension editor at Clemson University, where he earned a Masters Degree in English in 1975. He served as associate editor for Southeast Farm Press from 1978 through 1989. In 1990, Smith helped launch Southern Turf Management Magazine and served as editor. He also helped launch two other regional Turf and Landscape publications and launched and edited Florida Grove and Vegetable Management for the Farm Press Group. Within two years of launch, the turf magazines were well-respected, award-winning publications. Ron has received numerous awards for writing and photography in both agriculture and landscape journalism. He is past president of The Turf and Ornamental Communicators Association and was chosen as the first media representative to the University of Georgia College of Agriculture Advisory Board. He was named Communicator of the Year for the Metropolitan Atlanta Agricultural Communicators Association. More recently, he was awarded the Norman Borlaug Lifetime Achievement Award by the Texas Plant Protection Association. Smith also worked in public relations, specializing in media relations for agricultural companies. Ron lives with his wife Pat in Johnson City, Tenn. They have two grown children, Stacey and Nick, and three grandsons, Aaron, Hunter and Walker.

Subscribe to receive top agriculture news
Be informed daily with these free e-newsletters

You May Also Like