Kansas Farmer Logo

Agronomic practices have as much, or more, impact on yield than variety traits.

August 23, 2019

3 Min Read
combine in wheat field
IMPROVING YIELDS: Romulo Lollato, Kansas State University wheat and forage Extension specialist, says that elusive yield bump could come from tweaking agronomic practices.

With a number of excellent wheat varieties available to them, how can farmers gain that elusive yield bump? Management, says Romulo Lollato, wheat and forage Extension specialist at Kansas State University. With all the newest varieties offering similar benefits, agronomic practices have a greater influence on yield than variety selection does.

"I think we are at the point where we have so many excellent varieties that we don't have to be quite as picky. There are a lot of really good options, so we have to look at management, as well," Lollato says. "That's what the last 19 years of data that we have collected is telling us — that management practices are very, very important."

According to this data, management accounts for 44% to 77% of yield variation. Because of this large yield gap, Lollato says, "It is time to manage wheat."

To no one's surprise, region and irrigation make the top of the list for yield producing management practices, but application of foliar fungicide and sowing date are also incredibly important for both irrigated and dryland farmers. The largest yield drag was dual-purpose wheat used for grazing.

Sowing dates can have a huge impact on final yields, but the optimal sowing date varies by region.

Western Kansas farmers have an optimal date of Oct. 1, north central's optimal date is Oct. 10 and south central's is Oct. 12. Planting after these optimal dates can mean substantial yield penalties. The south-central region loses about 1.1 bushels per day for around 20 days following Oct. 12, but that loss increases to around 2.7 bushels per day after those initial 20. North-central Kansas consistently loses about 2.1 bushels per day, while the western region loses a whopping 3.5 bushels.

Lollato and his team have also found that seed treatments (such as insecticides and fungicides) have a higher yield bump in good seasons, while foliar fungicides are beneficial in all seasons but have more yield gain in those higher yielding seasons. Micronutrient applications have had a negligible bump during high performing years, while they have a monster gain of 9.7 bushels per acre during low performance years.

Lollato's research has also focused on sulfur. Kansas has seen the removal of sulfur from the soil during wheat production exceeding the amount of atmospheric deposition since 2000, which he attributes as an effect of the Clean Air Act.

This legislation has meant lower levels of air pollution, but less pollution means less sulfur coming in during rainfall. Sulfur application has a slight yield drag of about six-tenths of a bushel per acre during high performing years (such as 2016 and 2017) but had a net gain of around 4.9 bushels per acre during drier years such as 2018. He also advised that while sulfur and nitrogen deficiencies tend to have a similar yellowed appearance in plants, sulfur deficiency tends to express a brighter yellow discoloration in the upper plant canopy and nitrogen deficiency discolors the lower canopy.

Although management practices are the most reliable source of yield gain, variety traits can have an effect. Stripe rust resistance was the trait with the highest yield gain, but there are others to keep an eye on depending on region and management practices.

In the western region's irrigated wheat, stripe rust, coleoptile length, straw strength and winterhardiness are the highest yielding traits. For dryland wheat, those traits are drought tolerance, coleoptile length, first hollow stem date and stripe rust.

In the central region, if you're planning on applying fungicide, look for medium to late heading, drought tolerance, acid soil tolerance and medium to short height. With no fungicide application, those high-yielding traits are stripe rust tolerance, leaf rust tolerance, fall grazing potential, early heading date and drought tolerance.

Lolatto’s research projects were funded by the Kansas Wheat Commission and the Kansas Wheat Alliance. For more information on these research projects and others, please visit kansaswheat.org and kswheatalliance.org.

Source: Kansas Wheat, which is solely responsible for the information provided and is wholly owned by the source. Informa Business Media and all its subsidiaries are not responsible for any of the content contained in this information asset.

Subscribe to receive top agriculture news
Be informed daily with these free e-newsletters

You May Also Like