Farm Progress

Any bullish soybean story may be late this year

The poor crop conditions doesn't correlate with the projected yields so the market isn't rallying.

Kevin Van Trump, Founder

August 16, 2017

3 Min Read

Soybean traders are a bit surprised to see weekly crop conditions once again deteriorate, falling from 60% down to just 59% reported "Good-to-Excellent". This drop in conditions comes just a few days after the USDA surprised the trade by raising the national yield from 48.0 to 49.4 bushels per acre.

In other words the weekly crop conditions are deteriorating, now at 59% "Good-to-Excellent" vs. 72% last year, but the USDA's just reported their highest ever August yield forecast at 49.4 bushels per acre, actually higher than last years August estimate of 48.9 bushels per acre.

As I mentioned above in the corn commentary, the powers that be have told me time and time again that there's no real correlation between the weekly crop-condition opinions and the more objective yield forecasting that is delivered by NASS in the monthly report. Hence, we can jump up and down and yell until we are blue in the face, but the market continues, and obviously prefers, to trade the more objective monthly NASS numbers, which include farmer surveys, satellite imagery and samples taken directly from the fields.

Again, weekly crop conditions are much less science and research based and a lot more opinionated than the NASS monthly estimates. This is probably why the market is fairly quick to discount the weekly opinions and more apt to trade the monthly forecast. As I've said for several weeks, I wouldn't be surprised to see the NOV17 contract test the $9.00 to $9.20 range. To the upside, it seems like the $9.50 to $9.60 area has now become nearby resistance. As a spec, I still remain patient in looking for an opportunity to dip a toe in the water as a longer-term bull. I can both see and understand the possibility of a longer-term bullish story, but I still have a hard time with current market timing.

The South American crop is record large, the Chinese crop is forecast to be bigger than last year, U.S. demand headlines might backpedal a bit during the second half of 2017, and the record number of U.S. planted soybean acres are probably going to get even larger. Oh, and did I mention, the USDA just recently forecast the largest August yield estimate in our nations history. Record acres and record yield headlines are extremely tough for the bulls to battle day in and day out. In other words, I see no need to get in a hurry, we may have to get past the U.S. growing season before we are able to sustain a significant rally.

As a producer, I want to continue keeping my hedges in place and stick with my longer-term "wait-and-see" approach towards marketing any additional cash bushels. Weather looks bearish nearby as timely rains and cooler than normal temps limit crop stress in many key locations. Iowa remains highly variable and uncertain, but some nearby rains could help stabilize and improve the finishing efforts of the crop. The extended forecast still brings some uncertainty as temps warm back up and moisture becomes more limited.

GET ALL MY DAILY AG THOUGHTS HERE

About the Author

Kevin Van Trump

Founder, Farmdirection.com

Kevin is a leading expert in Agricultural marketing and analysis, he also produces an award-winning and world-recognized daily industry Ag wire called "The Van Trump Report." With over 20 years of experience trading professionally at the CME, CBOT and KCBOT, Kevin is able to 'connect-the-dots' and simplify the complex moving parts associated with today's markets in a thought provoking yet easy to read format. With thousands of daily readers in over 40 countries, Kevin has become a sought after source for market direction, timing and macro views associated with the agricultural world. Kevin is a top featured guest on many farm radio programs and business news channels here in the United States. He also speaks internationally to hedge fund managers and industry leading agricultural executives about current market conditions and 'black swan' forecasting. Kevin is currently the acting Chairman of Farm Direction, an international organization assembled to bring the finest and most current agricultural thoughts and strategies directly to the world's top producers. The markets have dramatically changed and Kevin is trying to redefine how those in the agricultural world can better manage their risk and better understand the adversity that lies ahead. 

Subscribe to receive top agriculture news
Be informed daily with these free e-newsletters

You May Also Like