Farm Progress

Equipment decisions: Lease vs. buy, part one

Asking the right questions is key to good machinery decisions.

Darren Frye, CEO

April 5, 2017

3 Min Read
ekinsdesigns/Thinkstock

As planting preparations are well underway, it’s critical to know your operation’s costs. That’s key information for a farm’s financial success. Your costs include things that come to mind right away – like inputs and fixed costs, but also machinery costs.

A metric you’ll want to be aware of as you get ready to plant is your machinery investment per acre. This is the total value of your machinery across all the acres you farm. It helps show the level of efficiency you’re currently achieving with your equipment line. Knowing this metric can help in recognizing any areas where you could work to increase efficiency.

Lease vs. buy
Here’s a machinery decision that’s been coming up the past few months with our farmer clients: Should I lease or buy this piece of equipment?

The farmer and their ag finance advisor work together to bring insight to that question. Usually, the farmer already has some idea or belief about what the final answer may be, but it can be a challenge to know exactly how either choice will impact the farm’s balance sheet.

One farmer was deciding whether to buy a new tractor or lease one, so he asked his ag finance advisor to help run the numbers and bring another perspective. The farmer’s potential lease payment and potential loan payment were very close in amount, so he wasn’t sure what to do.

The farmer and advisor talked about how the operation’s working capital was tight right now and about how the farmer was committed to preserving it as much as possible. On the other hand, his equity was in a good spot.

To help think through the decision a bit more, they talked through a few questions:

  • What’s the warranty on the lease like? Would it cover all repairs or only certain repairs? What might the potential repairs be on the tractor, if purchased? What’s the trade-off?

  • Is the lease an operating lease or a capital lease? If the lease has a buyout, is it a large or small percentage of its initial value?

  • Would it be beneficial for the operation to own another piece of machinery right now, or not?

Dig deeper
If you’re facing a decision on whether to lease or buy a piece of equipment, here are a few questions to ask yourself.

Take a look at your farm’s current financial state. If you were to make a down payment and take on an equipment loan, what will that do to your working capital and equity? Will they remain within good ranges?

  1. Where are you in your farming career? Will you be retiring soon or not for another 20-30 years?

  2. Does purchasing or leasing make more sense for your entity structure? For where the farm will be in five years? Do your expectations for production in five years change the logistics of needed machinery?

  3. Overall, what makes the most sense for the operation right now, both in terms of where you’re currently at financially and your goals for the operation over the next few years?

Next week, I’ll dive into some more details on questions you can use to evaluate equipment leases. If you’re facing a decision on whether to lease or buy a piece of machinery, you may want to talk with one of our ag finance advisors for additional help and perspective.

Read the current issue of the Smart Series publication, bringing business ideas for today’s farm leader. This issue includes perspectives on what to do when a landlord asks for higher rent, how to find the right new employee, a farm business checklist for the spring season, and more. Get your free online issue here.

The opinions of the author are not necessarily those of Farm Futures or Penton Agriculture.

About the Author(s)

Darren Frye

CEO, Water Street Solutions

Darren Frye grew up on an innovative, integrated Illinois farm. He began trading commodities in 1982 and started his first business in 1987, specializing in fertilizer distribution and crop consulting. In 1994 he started a consulting business, Water Street Solutions to help Midwest farmers become more successful through financial analysis, crop insurance, marketing consulting and legacy planning. The mission of Finance First is to get you to look at spreadsheets and see opportunity, to see your business for what it can be, and to help you build your agricultural legacy.

Visit Water Street Solutions

Subscribe to receive top agriculture news
Be informed daily with these free e-newsletters

You May Also Like