Sponsored By
American Agriculturist Logo

Scientists say limits on saturated fats unjustified

Letter sent to USDA, HHS urges lifting of limits placed on saturated fat intake in upcoming 2020 Dietary Guidelines for Americans.

February 26, 2020

4 Min Read

A group of nutrition scientists say current science fails to support a continuation of the government’s policy limiting consumption of saturated fats.

The group of nutrition scientists met Feb 10-11 for a two-day workshop, “Saturated Fats: A Food or Nutrient Approach?” The group included three former members of the Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee. The DGAC is an expert group, appointed every five years to review the science for the government’s nutrition policy, the U.S. Dietary Guidelines for Americans and make recommendations to the two agencies that jointly issue those guidelines, the USDA and the Department of Health and Human Services.

The workshop was organized by co-chairs Arne Astrup, MD, DMSc, and Ronald M. Krauss, MD, and was funded by The Nutrition Coalition, a non-profit, non-partisan educational organization based in Washington, D.C. It was founded in 2015 with the goal of ensuring that U.S. nutrition policy is based on scientific evidence.

Members of the group who met earlier this month wrote a consensus statement on saturated fats and also sent a letter regarding their findings to the Secretaries of USDA and HHS. The letter stated, “There is no strong scientific evidence that the current population-wide upper limits on commonly consumed saturated fats in the U.S. will prevent cardiovascular disease or reduce mortality. A continued limit on these fats is therefore not justified.”

The letter urged USDA-HHS to give “serious and immediate consideration to lifting the limits placed on saturated fat intake for the upcoming 2020 Dietary Guidelines for Americans.”

“We agreed that there is no evidence that the current population-wide upper limits on commonly consumed saturated fats in the U.S. will prevent cardiovascular disease or reduce mortality,” said Janet King, Ph.D., chair of the 2005 DGAC and a professor in the Department of Nutritional Sciences and Toxicology at the University of California at Berkeley.

Since the launch of the DGA in 1980, Americans have been advised to consume a diet “low in saturated fats.” In 2005, the DGA added a specific limit of 10% of calories from these fats, and this recommendation has endured since that time. For the 2020 DGA, the USDA-HHS advisory committee has stated that it will update the recommendations for saturated fats, with a report due out mid-May of this year.

“The guidelines determine school lunches, hospital food, feeding programs for the elderly and military food. Indeed, they influence our entire food supply. It is therefore critical that these guidelines be based on the best-possible science, including the most up-to-date understanding on saturated fats and their effects on health,” stated Ronald M. Krauss, MD, one of the workshop's two co-chairs and a professor of Pediatrics and Medicine at the University of California, San Francisco as well as the Dolores Jordan Endowed Chair at UCSF.

“The approach to look at saturated fat as one group, and to predict health effects of individual foods, meals and diets based on the total content of saturated fat is likely to lead to erroneous conclusions,” said Arne Astrup, MD, DMSc, a workshop co-chair and Professor, Head of Department of Nutrition, Exercise and Sports, University of Copenhagen & Chief Consultant, Unit for Clinical Research, Bispebjerg Frederiksberg Hospitals, Copenhagen, Denmark. “Future recommendations should move away from a nutrient-based analytical strategy to a food-based approach, and we hope these considerations will be taken into account before the DGA advisory committee’s scientific report is issued in May.”

A critically important consideration regarding saturated fat is the growing recognition by scientists in the field that the effect of these fats on health cannot be considered in isolation, but instead must be analyzed as part of the composition of specific foods in which these fats exist. It is now known that the impact of nutrients on health needs to be considered in the context of the overall diet, the type and degree of food processing that a food undergoes, and other crucial factors such as a person’s metabolic health and propensity for disease.

For example, some foods, such as dark chocolate, whole-fat dairy, and unprocessed meat, have a relatively high saturated-fat content but show no association with increased cardiovascular risk.

These leading researchers in the field also concluded that: 

  • Numerous recent meta-analyses of both controlled randomized trials and observational studies have found no significant evidence for effects of saturated fat consumption on cardiovascular or total mortality. Furthermore, there is evidence that saturated-fat intake may be associated with a lower risk of experiencing a stroke.

  • Recommendations to lower saturated fat consumption have been based primarily on the evidence that this will lower LDL, the type of cholesterol in the blood that has been linked to heart disease risk. However, it is now known that there is more than one type of LDL, and that in the majority of individuals, reducing dietary saturated fat does not lower the type (small dense LDL) that is most strongly associated with heart disease risk. This may help to explain why lowering saturated fat intake in trials has not been found to reduce cardiovascular mortality.

Source: The Nutrition Coalition, which is solely responsible for the information provided and is wholly owned by the source. Informa Business Media and all its subsidiaries are not responsible for any of the content contained in this information asset. 

Subscribe to receive top agriculture news
Be informed daily with these free e-newsletters

You May Also Like