Wallaces Farmer

How to choose between generic or branded fungicidesHow to choose between generic or branded fungicides

Newer branded fungicides protect corn from disease for a longer time. However, generics are less expensive and provide adequate protection if disease pressure surfaces later.

Gil Gullickson, Editor

December 10, 2024

1 Min Read
cornstalks
FUNGICIDE DECISION: Older, generic fungicides control disease and are less expensive than newer branded fungicides. However, they don’t provide disease protection as long as newer branded ones, according to Iowa State University trials. Gil Gullickson

When it comes to the length of disease protection, newer branded fungicides have an edge over generic ones, according to trials conducted by Iowa State University.

Newer branded fungicides protected corn from fungal diseases for about 35 days in ISU tests, says Alison Robertson, an ISU Extension plant pathologist. Meanwhile, generic fungicides have provided 21 days of fungal disease protection in ISU trials.

So why apply products with a shorter protection period? They’re less expensive. A branded product may cost $15 per acre, while a generic one may cost about $8 per acre, Robertson says.

Still, there’s a catch.

No fungicide — branded or generic — protects corn for the 60-day grain fill period from tasseling (VT) to R6 (black layer). That’s why Robertson advises farmers to aim fungicide applications from VT to R3 (kernel milk stage) to provide fungal disease protection during the most critical time of grain fill.

If disease surfaces around tasseling, applying a more expensive branded chemistry fends off fungal diseases for five weeks through the R4 (kernel dough) stage.

If disease pressure holds off until the R2 (brown silk/blister) stage, however, a less expensive generic can provide protection through R4, Robertson says. Fungicide application returns diminish greatly after the R4 stage, she adds.

Related:New seed treatment targets twin terrors of SDS and SCN

Farmers who opt for generic fungicides should use a product that has at least two modes of action or a mix of two products each with a different mode of action. “This reduces the chances of fungicide resistance developing,” Robertson says.

About the Author

Gil Gullickson

Editor, Wallaces Farmer

Gil Gullickson grew up on a farm that he now owns near Langford, S.D., and graduated with an agronomy degree from South Dakota State University. Earlier in his career, he spent 13 years as a Farm Progress editor, covering Minnesota and the Dakotas.

Gullickson is a widely respected and decorated ag journalist, earning the Agricultural Communicators Network writing award for Writer of the Year three times, and winning Story of the Year four times. He is a past winner of the International Federation of Agricultural Journalists’ Food and Agriculture Organization Award for Food Security. He has served as president of both ACN and the North American Agricultural Journalists.

Subscribe to receive top agriculture news
Be informed daily with these free e-newsletters

You May Also Like