Farm Progress

Are Organic Foods Over-hyped?Are Organic Foods Over-hyped?

July 30, 2010

2 Min Read

News accounts of organic agriculture and organic food are more likely to be positive than negative and inaccurately claim organic food is safer, according to Kansas State University's Doug Powell.

Powell, an associate professor of food safety, is the co-author of "Coverage of organic agriculture in North American newspapers: Media – linking food safety, the environment, human health and organic agriculture," just published in the British Food Journal.

The paper is based on a study Powell conducted from 1999-2004 with two colleagues at the University of Guelph in Canada, Stacey Cahill and Katija Morley. Cahill was one of Powell's students at the time. The team explored how topics of organic food and agriculture were discussed in five North American newspapers. Using the content analysis technique, the 618 articles collected were analyzed for topic, tone and theme regarding food safety, environmental concerns and human health.

The prominent topics of the articles were genetic engineering, pesticides and organic farming, says Powell. The analysis found 41.4% of the articles had a neutral tone toward organic agriculture and food, 36.9% had a positive tone, 15.5% were mixed and 6.1% were negative.

"We concluded that articles about organic production in the selected time period were seldom negative," he says. "Organic agriculture was often portrayed in the media as an alternative to allegedly unsafe and environmentally damaging modern agriculture practices. That means organic was being defined by what it isn't, rather than what it is."

USDA has repeatedly stated that the organic standard is a verification of production methods and not a food safety claim, says Powell. "Food safety was the least important in the media discussion of organic agriculture," he says. "The finding that 50% of food safety-themed statements in news articles were positive with respect to organic agriculture, while 81% of health-themed statements and 90% of environment-themed statements were positive toward organic food, indicates an uncritical press."

Subscribe to receive top agriculture news
Be informed daily with these free e-newsletters

You May Also Like