Kansas Farmer Logo

The taste of a memoryThe taste of a memory

Cowtowns & Skyscrapers: Christmas can be found in the smallest of things — even an antique cookie cutter and a lost recipe.

Jennifer M. Latzke, Editor

December 24, 2024

4 Min Read
Christmas cookies
COOKIES: A search for a special cookie cutter and a recipe brings memories of Christmases past.Lew Robertson/Getty Images

Some people take to hiking or hunting in nature to relieve their stress. Some folks find their rest and recharge in a good book and an hour of silence.

I prefer to wander through antique stores when my peace needs recharging.

The other day I took a solo jaunt to Wichita, Kan., to wander through antique stores. No real list in hand. No time limits. It’s especially fun to go antique shopping at Christmas. You’ll see decorations and things from your childhood that bring up memories of happier and simpler times.

That was the case for me with the box of red plastic cookie cutters I found in one booth.

See, I’ve been on a mission for about 20 years now to find the specific red Santa cookie cutter my grandma used to make her epic sugar cookies each year. And, more importantly, to find the recipe for the sugar cookies and the icing that was a perfect consistency for decorating.

You know how it is when someone passes. There’s just so much that gets lost in the packing and the sorting and the shuffling among relatives. A cookie cutter and a recipe aren’t really high priorities to save. But to me, well, they’re something that lets me picture my grandma in her apron, in the kitchen of their little house in Junction City, stirring a pot and talking about her latest quilt project on the frame in the basement. For her, cooking and baking for her family, and making quilts and Afghans, was her way of showing her love.

Related:Southwest Kansas leads the state’s agriculture industry

So when I saw the cookie cutters in that antique booth, I held my breath. I’d been disappointed before. Still, I pawed through the pile, hoping against hope that the particular Santa cutter would be in there.

And it was. Jackpot!

“Now all I have to do is track down the recipe,” I thought. The aunts have been on the trail for a while, looking in their boxes, but you know how life gets in the way. “That’s OK, I can experiment with recipes I find online until I find it,” I tell myself.

Then, a day ago, I was scrolling through Facebook — like one does to unwind at the end of the day. There, on an antique page, were photos of the original box that this cookie cutter set was originally sold in. (The one time that the Facebook algorithm overlords actually used their powers for good and not evil.) And in another picture, the inside of the box lid, which showed the recipes the manufacturer included for the housewife of the 1950s to use to make her own Christmas sugar cookies a smashing success.

Could it be that simple? Were Grandma’s cookie and icing recipes off the box lid?

This week I’ll be experimenting and seeing if I can’t recreate a little Christmas magic. I know they won’t be exactly the same. She had a touch for baking that I can’t quite re-create. But I think I’ll have an angel guiding my hand.

Related:Remembering Sam Stanley inspires us to forge ahead

With every bite, I hope to remember a time when my biggest worry was what present was under the tree for me. And when all it took to feel safe was a warm car ride to our country church’s Christmas Eve service, sitting on the rear bench seat between my older sister and older brother.

I tell you this story today, on Christmas Eve, to remind you that the longest lasting memories for our families aren’t found on Amazon or in the aisles of Walmart. Christmas isn’t found on a sale or in a flashy advertisement. It’s not found in expensive gifts that break or get tossed aside the minute the next model rolls out.

It’s in the time we spend with family and friends. It’s in acts of giving and service to our loved ones and to strangers. It’s in the small things, like a plastic cookie cutter and a sugar cookie recipe.

And, above all, it’s found in the story of a very special child’s birth in a stable, reminding us that the greatest gift of all is love.

Christmas sugar cookies and icing

This is the recipe off the box lid that I’ll be testing this week:

Related:Go out and make your 2025 great

½ cup shortening

1 cup sugar

2 well-beaten eggs

2 tbsp cream

1 tbsp. vanilla or almond

3 ½ cups cake flour

2 tsp. baking powder

Mix together and beat the shortening and sugar until light and fluffy. Add the eggs, cream and vanilla or almond and beat well. Sift together, separately, the cake flour and baking powder. Add the sifted dry ingredients to the creamed mixture. Shape into a mound, wrap in plastic and chill thoroughly. Roll chilled dough on a board lightly dusted with confectioners’ sugar until the dough is about ¼ inch thick. Dip cookie cutter in confectioners’ sugar each time before cutting a cookie. Place cookies on a lightly greased baking sheet. Bake at 375 degrees for about eight minutes or until delicately browned.

For icing, take one unbeaten egg white and add up to 1 cup of confectioners’ sugar gradually and a few grains of salt, beating until smooth and a consistency to pour slightly. Color and flavor as desired.

About the Author

Jennifer M. Latzke

Editor, Kansas Farmer

Through all her travels, Jennifer M. Latzke knows that there is no place like Kansas.

Jennifer grew up on her family’s multigenerational registered Angus seedstock ranch and diversified farm just north of Woodbine, Kan., about 30 minutes south of Junction City on the edge of the Kansas Flint Hills. Rock Springs Ranch State 4-H Center was in her family’s backyard.

While at Kansas State University, Jennifer was a member of the Sigma Kappa Sorority and a national officer for the Agricultural Communicators of Tomorrow. She graduated in May 2000 with a bachelor’s degree in agricultural communications and a minor in animal science. In August 2000 Jennifer started her 20-year agricultural writing career in Dodge City, Kan., on the far southwest corner of the state.

She’s traveled across the U.S. writing on wheat, sorghum, corn, cotton, dairy and beef stories as well as breaking news and policy at the local, state and national levels. Latzke has traveled across Mexico and South America with the U.S. Wheat Associates and toured Vietnam as a member of KARL Class X. She’s traveled to Argentina as one of 10 IFAJ-Alltech Young Leaders in Agricultural Journalism. And she was part of a delegation of AAEA: The Ag Communicators Network members invited to Cuba.

Jennifer’s an award-winning writer, columnist, and podcaster, recognized by the Kansas Professional Communicators, Kansas Press Association, the National Federation of Presswomen, Livestock Publications Council, and AAEA. In 2019, Jennifer reached the pinnacle of achievements, earning the title of “Writer of Merit” from AAEA.

Trips and accolades are lovely, but Jennifer says she is happiest on the road talking to farmers and ranchers and gathering stories and photos to share with readers.

“It’s an honor and a great responsibility to be able to tell someone’s story and bring them recognition for their work on the land,” Jennifer says. “But my role is also evolving to help our more urban neighbors understand the issues our Kansas farmers face in bringing the food and fiber to their store shelves.”

She spends her time gardening, crafting, watching K-State football, and cheering on her nephews and niece in their 4-H projects. She can be found on Twitter at @Latzke.

Subscribe to receive top agriculture news
Be informed daily with these free e-newsletters

You May Also Like