Delta Farm Press Logo

Is Daylight Savings Time necessary?Is Daylight Savings Time necessary?

Only a government would cut off an inch from the bottom of a blanket and sew it to the top. – an oft quoted Native American observation.

Brent Murphree, Senior Editor

January 9, 2025

2 Min Read
Sunrise DST
DST messes up my circadian rhythm twice a year. It always takes a week or so for my body to adjust to the new time change. Brent Murphree

I have some firmly rooted opinions about Daylight Savings Time and have had them since I was a teenager.

As a pragmatist, I believe in practical, real-time solutions. That play on words may give you an indication where I am going with all of this, but in my opinion, real time doesn’t suffer the human notion of more daylight by Congressional act.

As an oft quoted, but unidentified Native American once said, “Only a government (paleface, white man) would cut off an inch (2-inches, foot) from a blanket and sew it to the top.” The many versions of the quote are unclear on the source or the content of the quote, only indicating that it references DST.

I believe that the wise man who made the point is correct.

Benjamin Franklin is often noted as a source for the idea of DST. The Journal de Paris published a satire letter he wrote in 1784 advocating taxing window shutters, candle rationing and ringing church bells to wake the public at sunrise. But that was at a time when agrarian society was rising with the sun as they had always done. I think Franklin was urging the privileged urbanites of his time to get up off their rear ends and do something productive early in the day, as he was in the habit of doing.

I couldn’t find an actual plan devised by Franklin to establish something like DST.

Related:Irrigation efficiency keeps going up

Seasonal changes and wartime lighting restrictions were the impetus for the discussions that began in earnest in the late 1800s and into the 20th Century regarding DST. The Uniform Time Act of 1966 was enacted to “promote the adoption and observance of uniform time” within the U.S.

DST didn’t become the norm until after 1974 and there are some outliers who do not observe DST like Hawaii, Arizona and some Native American nations.

A misnomer is that farmers were big advocates of DST. The only thing farmers rely on their wristwatch for is lunchtime and maybe an irrigation schedule, but even those are relative to what is going on - weather, harvest crunch – in the field.

For me, DST is akin to jet lag. It messes up my circadian rhythm twice a year. It always takes a week or so for my body to adjust to the new time change.

I’m usually up before the sun rises, but the adjustment to the schedule of the time change is difficult for my aging mind.

More difficult for me than the time adjustment is the practical notion that actual time is relative. For me, if the sun is straight up, it’s noon on Earth. If we say it’s not, it’s the same thing as saying everything else is relative – fast/slow, old/new, hot/cold, dark/light.

Related:The magic of junk drawers

So, as discussions about doing away with DST come from the new administration, that’s where I stand.

Read more about:

Time Management

About the Author

Brent Murphree

Senior Editor, Delta Farm Press

Brent Murphree grew up on a third-generation Arizona cotton farm and has been in ag communications for well over 25 years. He received his journalism degree from the Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication at Arizona State University. He was a partner in the family farm, which grew cotton, wheat, alfalfa and pistachios. Urban encroachment in the fast-growing Phoenix metropolitan area was the impetus for closing the farm operation.

He received two Arizona Newspaper Association awards while at Kramer Communications in Casa Grande, Ariz., and was editor of their Pinal Ways magazine. He has served as a municipal public information officer and has worked as a communications director for the cotton industry, writing for industry publications. He was vice mayor of the town of Maricopa, which he helped incorporate, for seven years, having established and organized several community organizations in the process. His small hometown has grown from several hundred people to over 60,000 in just over 20 years.

Brent joined Farm Press in 2019 as content director for Southwest Farm Press and Western Farm Press. He became editor of Delta Farm Press in October of 2020.

Subscribe to receive top agriculture news
Be informed daily with these free e-newsletters

You May Also Like