Farm Progress is part of the Informa Markets Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them. Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.

Legislature should leave immigrants alone

Legislature should leave immigrants alone
Thousands of Latinos protest bills before Wisconsin Legislature

Just when you thought the Republican controlled Legislature was through with introducing controversial legislation that riles up and angers large numbers of people in Wisconsin you realize they're at it again.

Owners of large dairy farms scrambled on Feb. 18 to get their cows milked and allow as many workers as possible to attend the rally.

They introduced Assembly Bill 450/Senate Bill 369 which would lead police to investigate people's immigration status and detain undocumented individuals for deportation, similar to "a show me your papers law" in Arizona. Police would be allowed to ask immigrants to show them their papers even if they are stopped for a traffic violation. They also introduced Senate Bill 533/Assembly Bill 723 which would block city and county governments statewide from issuing local identification cards to people who can't access state IDs.

Many Latinos believe these bills unfairly target them. Th Owners of large dairy farms scrambled on Feb. 18 to get their cows milked and allow as many workers as possible to attend the rally. ey say these bills will prohibit immigrants from reporting crimes and coming forward to testify if they witness a crime.

As a result, some 20,000 Latinos, including thousands who work on dairy farms, dairy farmers, students and business owners, rallied at the state capitol in Madison on Feb. 18 in protest of these bills which many believe is anti-immigrant. The rally was also held to draw attention to the importance of immigrant workers in Wisconsin.

At the peak of the rally, police estimated 20,000 people filled the Capitol and its grounds. There were no arrests, and Madison police called the crowd peaceful and respectful. It was the biggest rally at the Capitol since 2011 when thousands occupied the Capitol and the surrounding area for three weeks opposing limits on collective bargaining.

Owners of large dairy farms scrambled on Feb. 18 to get their cows milked and allow as many workers as possible to attend the rally. Some paid employees overtime wages to milk before and after attending the rally. Others filled in and handled the work with a skeleton crew. Some farmers attended the protest themselves and called Republican legislators to let them know that they were angry and said they opposed any legislation that makes life more difficult for their employees.

According to a University of Wisconsin-Madison study, immigrants account for more than 40% of the hired labor on Wisconsin dairy farms. Without immigrants many large dairy producers say they would be forced to quit milking cows because there aren't enough other people willing to do the work. According to that same study, nearly 90% of Wisconsin's immigrant dairy workers are from Mexico.

Voting along party lines two days before the rally, the Senate and Assembly passed SB533 and sent it to Gov. Scott Walker for his signature. If Walker signs the bill into law, it will curtail identification cards issued by local governments. On the same day, the Assembly approved the bill on asking suspects about their immigration status, but it is unclear if Senate GOP leaders will take it up.

If Republican lawmakers were trying to unite Democrats, Latinos and large dairy farmers in Wisconsin, then introducing these two bills overwhelmingly accomplished that goal. Immigration reform is a complicated issue that needs to be addressed at the national level. 

Hide comments


  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <blockquote> <br> <p>

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.